How to Promote Your Restaurant Business:
A Pizza Marketing Case Study

Restaurant Case Study:
Capozzi's New York Pizza

The Situation

In 2005, local pizza restaurant owner John “Bud” Capozzi was seeking the answer to a pressing question:  How to promote your restaurant business in the local community?

Capozzi’s opened to create a casual family friendly atmosphere with mouthwatering menu items perfected from growing up in New York. Although Capozzi’s was establishing a great reputation with their customers, most new customers were acquired from word-of-mouth marketing.

With a small location in a suburban strip mall that can hardly be seen from the road, Capozzi’s realized they needed a fresh new strategy to bring in new pizza customers and compete with some of the bigger restaurant chains in the community.

The Solution - Targeted Direct Mail Campaign to New Movers

Welcomemat presented Capozzi’s with an innovative and turnkey approach to targeted direct mail marketing. The solution? A new mover marketing program infused with long-term ROI tracking and detailed demographics reporting.

Capozzi’s branded direct mail piece for the Welcomemat Program features a one-time gift offer for a free 16″ cheese pizza. Offering a welcome gift brings in the customers who have the highest likelihood of coming back and paying full price for the next 5.6 years, rather than discount-driven customers who are often only as loyal as the next discount.

Welcomemat’s patented data models allow Capozzi’s to target a certain amount of new movers every month to build a steady stream of new customers throughout the year. Capozzi’s also claimed exclusivity over their target area, allowing Capozzi’s to be the only pizza restaurant inviting new residents to try their delicious pizza.

With a simple scanner app to scan in Welcomemat redemptions and unlimited ROI tracking to prove the program’s success, the results below exceeded Capozzi’s expectations!

The Results


Number of Years Using
the Welcomemat Program


Response Rate


Average Yearly Number of New Customers from the Welcomemat Program


ROI from New Welcomemat Customers

The ROI from new pizza restaurant customers gained at Capozzi’s has outweighed the average monthly direct mail advertising costs for the Welcomemat Program month over month for 14+ years!

Capozzi’s sees a redemption rate of 7% on the Welcomemat mailer, which is more than 3X the average direct mail response rate of 2%!

Capozzi’s 14 years of Welcomemat redemption data show an average of 424 new customers a year from the new mover program.

Utilizing national pizza industry standards for the average amount a typical pizza customer spends in a year, a marketing ROI of 667% after accounting for the Welcomemat Program costs can be calculated.

Contact us today or more information on Welcomemat’s New Mover Program and ROI tracking!

Check Us Out!

The Welcomemat program has become a staple of Capozzi’s restaurant marketing plan, bringing in 400+ new, repeat customers year over year!

In 2015, Capozzi’s celebrated their 10-Year Anniversary of being a Welcomemat client. The local Welcomemat team stopped by to Capozzi’s for lunch to thank them for being such a valued partner over the years. The Capozzi’s and Welcomemat teams had a blast, and our team was raving about their delicious meal for weeks!

The Capozzi’s story is a powerful example of how to promote your restaurant business in the local community.


Want to Find Out How to Promote Your Restaurant Business to New Movers?

The Welcomemat team will be happy to help you learn more about our custom new mover marketing programs! Get in touch today for a free new mover analysis in your local area!

Get in Touch for a Free New Mover Analysis Today!